소음인병증(少陰人病證) 내에서의 소증(素證)의 임상적 의미와 소증(素證)에 따른 현증(現證) 전개양상에 대한 고찰(考察)

이준희,이의주,고병희,Lee, Jun-Hee,Lee, Eui-Ju,Koh, Byung-Hee 사상체질의학회 2012 사상체질의학회지 Vol.24 No.3

Objectives We aimed to analyze the meanings of ordinary symptoms and the developing aspects of present symptoms according to the ordinary symptoms based on the Soeumin pathology, and present the new methodology to make use of the ordinary symptoms in the clinical field. Methods The Soeumin symptomatology and pathology of the Sinchuk Edition (the upgraded and revised edition) of "Donguisusebowon" were reviewed and examined for relevant information on the ordinary symptoms. Results and Conclusions 1) In the Soeumin symptomatology, the representative symptoms, by which the aspects of whole physio-pathological conditions can be decided, were showed as ordinary symptoms, and especially the aggravated state of the deflection of Seong-Jeong are presented additionally in the ordinary symptoms of the unfavorable patterns of Exterior and Interior symptomatologies. 2) In the Soeumin symptomatology, the ordinary symptoms have the clinical meanings as 'pathological predisposition', and can be estimated as one symptomatology in the whole schemes of symptomatology. 3) In the Soeumin symptomatology, the ordinary symptoms can affect the present symptoms, and can be the principal factors in the pattern identifications of the present symptoms and the determinations of therapeutical prescriptions. 4) In the Soeumin symptomatology, the ordinary symptoms can develop to the present symptoms across the Interior or the Exterior symptomatologies within the categories of the favorable and unfavorable patterns, and this developing aspects can be explained from the Soeumin pathological perspective.

파킨슨병에서의 감각증상 동아대학교 의과대학 신경과학교실

김상우,차재관,김상호,김재우 대한신경과학회 1998 대한신경과학회지 Vol.16 No.3

The Relationship between Depressive Symptoms in Outpatients with Chronic Illness and Health Care Costs

Na, Yu-Mi,Kim, Kwang-Soo,Lee, Kyoung-Uk,Chae, Jeong-Ho,Kim, Jin-Ho,Kim, Dai-Jin,Bahk, Won-Myong,Jang, Yun-Sig,Lee, Ae-Kyoung,Woo, Young Sup,Lee, Pyeoung-Soo Yonsei University, College of Medicine 2007 Yonsei medical journal Vol.48 No.5

<P><B>Purpose</B></P><P>To evaluate the relationship between depressive symptoms and health care costs in outpatients with chronic medical illnesses in Korea, we screened for depressive symptoms in 1,118 patients with a chronic medical illness and compared the severity of somatic symptoms and health care costs.</P><P><B>Patients and Methods</B></P><P>Data were compared between outpatients with depressive symptoms and those without depressive symptoms. Depression and somatic symptoms were measured by Zung's Self-rating Depression Scale (SDS) and Patient Health Questionnaire (PHQ)-15, respectively. We also investigated additional data related to patients' health care costs (number of visited clinical departments, number of visits made per patients, and health care costs). A total of 468 patients (41.9%) met the criteria for depressive disorder.</P><P><B>Results</B></P><P>A high rate of severe depressive symptoms was found in elderly, female and less-educated patients. A positive association between the severity of somatic symptoms and depressive symptoms was also identified. The effects of depressive symptoms in patients with chronic illnesses on three measures of health services were assessed by controlling for the effects of demographic variables and the severity of somatic symptoms. We found that the effects of depressive symptoms on the number of visited departments and number of visits made per patients were mediated by the severity of somatic symptoms. However, for health care costs, depressive symptoms had a significant main effect. Furthermore, the effect of gender on health care costs is moderated by the degree of a patient's depressive symptoms.</P><P><B>Conclusion</B></P><P>In summary, there is clearly a need for increased recognition and treatment of depressive symptoms in outpatients with chronic medical illnesses.</P>

소화기 증상을 주소로 내원한 외래환자 991명에 대한 위장관 증상 및 동반 증상 분석

나병조(Byung-Jo Na),최서형(Seo-Hyung Choi) 대한한의학회 2012 대한한의학회지 Vol.33 No.1

공황 장애 환자의 공황 발작 증상의 특성

임기영,김창기,노재성 大韓神經精神醫學會 1996 신경정신의학 Vol.35 No.4

공황 장애가 새로운 질병으로 분류된지 16년이 경과하였으나 공황 발작과 공황장애의 본질과 특성에 관해서는 아직 명확히 알려져 있지 않다. 또한 현재의 DSM-IV 진단 기준 역시 공황 발작과 공황 장애의 정의 및 진단에 대해 상호 모순되는 기술을 하고 있음을 발견할 수 있고 공황 발작의 각 증상에 대해서도 나열에 그치고 있을 뿐 어떤 것이 더 중요하고, 어떤 것이 최초 증상인지 등을 밝혀 주지 못하고 있다. 따라서 저자들은 공황 장애 환자들의 공황 발작 증상의 특성을 보다 자세히 알아보기 위하여 아주대학교 병원 정신과 외래 및 응급실로 내원한 40명의 공황 장애 환자들을 대상으로 공황 발작 설문지, 불안 민감도 검사, 상태-특성 불안 검사, Beck의 불안 검사를 실시하여 다음과 같은 결과를 얻었다. 1) 공황 장애 환자들이 공황 발작시 최초로 경험하는 증상들은 대부분 신체 증상(90%)이었으며, 공황 발작의 인지 증상과 신체 증상은 높은 상관관계(0.741, P<0.01)가 있었다. 2) 인지 증상(0.695, P<0.01)과 신체증상(0.599, P<0.01) 모두는 임소공포증적 회피의 정도와 유의한 정적 상관 관계를 나타내었다. 그러나 신체 증상을 통제 변인으로 하여 인지 증상과 임소공포증적 회피와의 부분상관을 구한 결과는 유의한 상관이 있었으나(0.467, P=0.003), 반대로 인지 증상을 통제변인으로 하여 신체 증상과 임소공포증적 회피의 부분 상관을 구한 결과는 통계적으로 의미 있는 상관 관계가 없었다.(0.173, P=0.291). 3) 인지 증상은 ASI상의 불안 민감도 (0.563, P<0.01), STAI상 상태(0.324, P<0.05) 및 특성 불안(0.484, P<0.01), BAI상의 불안(0.456, P<0.01)과 정적 상관을 보였다. 신체 증상은 ASI 상의 불안 민감도(0.528, P<0.01), STAI 중 특성불안(0.411, P<0.01), 그리고 BAI 상의 불안(0.348, P<0.05)과는 정적상관을 나타내었으나, STAI 중 상태 불안(0.171)과는 의미 있는 상관이 나타나지 않았다. 4) 인지 증상과 신체 증상과 신체 증상 각각에 대해 상대 증상을 통제 변인으로 하여 부분 상관을 구해 본 결과, 신체증상은 각종 불안 검사상의 불안 및 민감도와 통제적으로 의미 있는 상관을 보이지 않았지만 인지 증상은 의미 있는 상관을 나타내었다. 이상의 결과들은 공황 발작이 본질적으로 신체증상이 선행되고, 인지 증상이 부수되는 복합현상이며, 인지증상의 정도에 따라 심리적 불안의 정도와 불안 민간도가 높아져서 공황 증세로 진행되고, 역시 인지 증상의 정도에 따라 임소공포증적 회피가 결정됨을 시사한다. 따라서 공황 발작의 13가지 진단 기준 항목은11가지 신체 증상만으로 줄이고, 2가지 인지 증상(죽을 것 같은 공포 및 미치거나 자제력을 잃게 될 것 같은 공포)은 공황 장애의 진단 기준에 포함시키며 이때 공황이 일어난 상황으로부터 벗어나려는 생각을 공황 장애의 인지 증상에 추가하는 것이 보다 정확한 진단 기준이 될 것으로 판단된다. It has been 16 years since panic disorder was first classified as a psychiatric disease entity. However, the nature and characteristics of panic attacks and panic disorder are not fully understood yet. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual, Fourth Edition(DSM-IV) carries conflicting statements regarding the definitions and diagnostic criteria of the panic attacks and panic disorder. Moreover, the DSM-IV only checks the presence or absence of each symptom, while failing to clarify which of each panic symptom are the earlier or more important symptoms. This study was designed to investigate the nature and characteristics of the panic attack symptoms. Forty outpatients diagnosed with DSM-IV panic disorder criteria were the subjects. All the subjects completed Panic Attack Questionnaire, Anxiety Sensitivity Index, State-Trait Anxiety Inventory, and Becks Anxiety Inventory. Results were as follows : 1) Majority(90%) of the subjects experienced somatic symptoms as the first symptom of their panic attack, and there was a significant correlation (0.741, P<0.01) between the somatic symptoms and the cognitive symptoms of panic attack. 2) Both cognitive symptoms(0.695, P<0.01) and somatic symptoms(0.599, P<0.01) showed significant correlation with agoraphobic avoidance. However, in partial correlation using somatic and cognitive symptoms as control variables for each other, only cognitive symptoms showed significant correlation with agoraphobic avoidance(0.467, P=0.003). 3) Cognitive symptoms showed significant correlation with the anxiety sensitivity(0.563, P<0.001), state anxiety(0.324, P<0.05), trait anxiety(0.484, P<0.01), and Becks anxiety(0.456, P<0.01). Somatic symptoms also showed significant correlation with the anxiety sensitivity(0.528, P<0.01), trait anxiety(0.411, P<0.01), Becks anxiety(0.348, P<0.05), but not with the state anxiety(0.171). 4) In partial correlation using somatic and cognitive symptoms as control variables for each other, cognitive symptoms showed statistically significant correlation with anxiety sensitivity and anxiety levels, while the somatic symptoms did not show such correlations. These results suggest that panic attack is a complex phenomenon in which the somatic symptoms are "triggers", and the cognitive symptoms are secondary reactions to the somatic symptoms. Psychological anxiety and anxiety sensitivity increase in proportion to the cognitive symptoms of the panic attack, which are important in the clinical process of panic disorder. The severity of cognitive symptoms also determines the development of agoraphobic avoidance. The authors propose to revise the diagnostic criteria of panic attack by the somatic symptoms only, and include cognitive symptoms, such as the desire to escape from the scene of panic attack, as necessary diagnostic criteria for panic disorder.

연취급 근로자의 연폭로 수준에 따른 주관적 자각증상 호소율

정두신,김화성,안규동,이병국,Jeong, Du-Shin,Kim, Hwa-Sung,Ahn, Kyu-Dong,Lee, Byung-Kook 대한예방의학회 1993 Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health Vol.26 No.2

연폭로의 정도와 자각증상과의 관계를 알아보기 위하여 435명의 연폭로 남자 근로자와 212명의 일반 사무직 남자 근로자를 대상으로 연폭로 지표가 되는 혈중 연, 혈중 Zinc Protoporphyrin(ZPP), 요중 Delta-aminolevulinic acid(DALA), 혈색소, 혈구 용적 측정을 위한 혈액 시료 및 소변 시료를 채취하여 분석하였고, 연관련 자각증상 조사는 14개의 증상 조사 항목을(표 3 및 별첨 1) 피검자가 응답 하도록하여 상담 의사의 면접을 통한 확인을 거쳐 수집 하였다. 수집된 각 항목은 인체 조직계 증상군별로 1) 위장관계 증상 2) 신경과 근육 및 관절계 증상 3) 일반 체질적 증상 4) 정신과적 증상으로 구분하여 연폭로 지표 수준과 연폭로 작업 여부에 따른 자각증상 호소율을 비교 조사하여 얻은 결론은 다음과 같다. 1. 연폭로군에서 대조군보다 유의하게 높은 자각증상 호소율을 보인 증상군은 신경과 근육 및 관절계 증상으로 "손이나 발이 저리거나 쥐가 잘난다", "관절이 아프거나 쑤신다", "손가락, 손, 발 등에 힘이 없다", "근육통을 느낀다" 순 이었다. 2. 연폭로군과 대조군의 자각증상 호소율에 가장 큰 차이를 보인 증상 항목은 "손이나 발이 저리거나 쥐가 잘 난다"였으며, 전체 조사 대상에서 가장 높은 증상 호소율을 보인 증상 항목은 일반 체질적 자각 증상군의 "전보다 피곤감을 느낀다"였다. 3. 전체 조사 대상의 혈중 연과 혈중 ZPP 수준에 따른 연폭로량의 증가와 자각증상 호소율의 증가를 보인 증상 항목은 신경과 근육 및 관절계 증상군의 "손이나 발이 저리거나 쥐가 잘난다", "관절이 아프거나 쑤신다", "손가락. 손 발 등에 힘이 없다", "근육통을 느낀다"와 위장관계 증상군의 "아랫배가 아파서 고생한 적이 있다"였다. 4 연폭로군에서 혈중 연과 혈중 ZPP 수준에 따른 연폭로량의 증가와 자각증상 호소율의 증가를 보인 증상 항목은 신경과 근육 및 관절계 증상으로 혈중 연의 증가에 따라 증상 호소율이 증가하였다. 5. 연폭로군에서 39세 이하 와 40세 이상 연령군으로 나누어 비교시 39세 이하 군의 증상 호소율이 40세 이상 군보다 높게 나왔으며. 신경과 근육 및 관절계 증상이 39세이하 군에서 혈중 연의 증가와 함께, 40세 이상 군에서 혈중 ZPP의 증가와 함께 자각증상 호소율의 증가를 나타냈다. 6. 연폭로 지표에 따른 폭로수준과 증상 호소율과의 관계를 알아보기 위하여 대조군에 대한 폭로군, 연폭로군의 저농도 폭로군에 대한 고농도 폭로군의 교차비를 산출한 결과 신경과 근육 및 관절계 증상군의 "손이나 발이 저리거나 쥐가 잘난다", "관절이 아프거나 쑤신다", "손가락, 손, 발 등에 힘이 없다", "근육통을 느낀다"와 위장관계 증상군의 "아랫배가 아파서 고생한 적이 있다"가 연폭로량의 증가에 따른 교차비의 증가를 보여 양-반응의 관계를 추정할 수 있었다. The relationship between lead related subject symptoms and lead exposure indices was studied in 435 male lead workers in thirteen lead using industries. 212 male office workers who were not exposed to lead occupationally were also studied as a control group. Fourteen lead related symptoms were selected. They were further subdivied into 4 sub-symptom groups such as 1) gastrointestinal, 2) neuromuscular and joint 3) constitutional, and 4) psychological symptoms. Symptom questionnaires were provided to the workers and filled up by themselves and reconfirmed by interviewer(doctor). The test used fer the evaluation of lead exposure were blood lead(PbB), zinc protoporphyrin in whole blood(ZPP), hemoglobin(Hb), hematocrit (Hct), delta-aminolevulinic acid in urine(DALA). The results obtained were as follows; 1. The higher prevalence rate in the sub-group of neuromuscular and joint symptoms was observed in occupationally lead exposed subjects than non-exposed subjects. Among the sub-groups, the most frequent symptom was 'numbness of finger, hands or feet', and the prevalence of the symptom of 'arthralgia', 'weakness of fingers, hands or feet' and 'myalgia' were higher in order. 2. While the symptom which showed the biggest difference of prevalence rate among the 14 symptoms between exposed and non-exposed subjects was 'numbness of fingers, hands or feet', the symptom which showed the highest prevalence rate was 'feeling tired generally' in exposed and non-exposed subjects, but no statistical difference of symptom prevalence were observed. 3. In total study population, PbB and ZPP had dose-response relationship with 4 symtoms of neuromuscular and joint symptoms ('numbness of finger, hands or feet', 'arthralgia', 'weakness of fingers, hands or feet' and 'myalgia') and one symptom of gastrointestinal group('intermittent pains in lower abdomen'). 4. In lead exposed workers, only neuromuscular and joint symptoms group showed dose-response relationship with PbB and ZPP, 5. In lead exposed workers, the prevalance rate of overall symptoms of lead workers with age below 39 years was higher than that of lead workers with age above 40. While neuromuscular and joint symptoms group had a dose-response relationship with PbB in former group, it had a dose-response relationship with ZPP in latter group. 6. Age adjusted odds ratios of symptoms of non-exposed with exposed and odds ratios of low exposed with high exposed workers showed the dose-response relationship of lead exposure with neuromuscular and joint symptoms group('numbness of fingers, hands or feet', 'arthralgia', 'weakness of fingers, hands or feet' and 'myalgia') and gastrointestinal symptoms group('intermittent pains in lower abdoman').

전립선 비대 증상 자각군과 일반 남성군의 전립선 비대 증상, 일상생활 활동, 성생활 만족 및 안녕감 비교

이규은,오점숙,김현주,김남선 성인간호학회 2003 성인간호학회지 Vol.15 No.3

Purpose: This study was designed to explore and compare the prostatic hypertrophoc symptoms, activities of daily living, satisfaction of sexual activities and well-being among subjects with prostatic hypertrophic symptoms and the general population. Method: One hundred subjects with prostatic hypertrophic symptoms and one hundred general persons were recruited in K medical center. The data were collected from October 20, 2001 to March 30, 2002 by structured questionnaire. Result: The results were the following; 1. The percentage of mild(0~7), moderate(8~19) and severe(20~35) symptoms between subjects with prostatic hypertrophic symptoms and general persons were 6% : 60%, 54% : 39%, 40% : 1%. 2. There was a significant difference in prostatic hypertrophic symptoms(t=12.82, p<.001), in activities of daily living(t=-7.77, p<.0001), in satisfaction of sexual activities (t=-4.80, p<.0001), in well-being(t=-4.80, p<.0001) between subjects with prostatic hypertrophic symptoms and general persons 3. There was a significant difference in activities of daily living(F=16.28, p<.0001), satisfaction of sexual activities(F=3.98, p<.05) according to prostatic hypertrophic symptoms in subjects with prostatic hypertrophic symptoms. Conclusion : According to the above findings, prostatic hypertrophic symptoms influence activities of daily living, satisfaction of sexual activities, well-being of subjects with prostatic hypertrophic symptoms negatively.

Patient’s Perception of Symptoms Related to Morning Activity in Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease: The SYMBOL Study

김연재,이병기,정치영,전영준,현대성,김경찬,유성근,최혜숙,신원혁,이관호 대한내과학회 2012 The Korean Journal of Internal Medicine Vol.27 No.4

Background/Aims: Patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) experience more problematic respiratory symptoms and have more trouble performing daily activities in the morning. The aim of this study was to assess the perception of COPD symptoms related to morning activities in patients with severe airflow limitation. Methods: Data of 133 patients with severe airflow limitation were analyzed in a prospective, non-interventional study. A clinical symptom questionnaire was completed by patients at baseline. In patients having morning symptoms, defined by at least one or more prominent or aggravating symptom during morning activities, a morning activity questionnaire was also completed at baseline and following 2 months of COPD treatment. Results: The most frequently reported COPD symptom was breathlessness (90.8%). Morning symptoms were reported in 76 (57%) patients; these had more frequent and severe clinical COPD symptoms. The most frequently reported morning activity was getting out of bed (82.9%). The long acting muscarinic antagonist (odds ratio [OR], 6.971;95% confidence interval [CI], 1.317 to 11.905) and chest tightness (OR, 0.075; 95% CI, 0.011 to 0.518) were identified as significantly related to absence of morning symptoms. There was no significant correlation between the degree of forced expiratory volume in 1 second improvement and severity score differences of all items of morning activity after 2-month treatment. Conclusions: Fifty-seven percent of COPD patients with severe airflow limitation have morning symptoms that limit their morning activities. These patients also have more prevalent and severe COPD symptoms. The results of this study therefore provide valuable information for the development of patient-reported outcomes in COPD. Background/Aims: Patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) experience more problematic respiratory symptoms and have more trouble performing daily activities in the morning. The aim of this study was to assess the perception of COPD symptoms related to morning activities in patients with severe airflow limitation. Methods: Data of 133 patients with severe airflow limitation were analyzed in a prospective, non-interventional study. A clinical symptom questionnaire was completed by patients at baseline. In patients having morning symptoms, defined by at least one or more prominent or aggravating symptom during morning activities, a morning activity questionnaire was also completed at baseline and following 2 months of COPD treatment. Results: The most frequently reported COPD symptom was breathlessness (90.8%). Morning symptoms were reported in 76 (57%) patients; these had more frequent and severe clinical COPD symptoms. The most frequently reported morning activity was getting out of bed (82.9%). The long acting muscarinic antagonist (odds ratio [OR], 6.971;95% confidence interval [CI], 1.317 to 11.905) and chest tightness (OR, 0.075; 95% CI, 0.011 to 0.518) were identified as significantly related to absence of morning symptoms. There was no significant correlation between the degree of forced expiratory volume in 1 second improvement and severity score differences of all items of morning activity after 2-month treatment. Conclusions: Fifty-seven percent of COPD patients with severe airflow limitation have morning symptoms that limit their morning activities. These patients also have more prevalent and severe COPD symptoms. The results of this study therefore provide valuable information for the development of patient-reported outcomes in COPD.

신체증상 및 기분증상을 주증상으로 호소하는 우울증 환자군의 비교 : In relation with somatic symptoms and stressful life events

김덕호,이상연,장환일 대한적십자사 2000 적십자병원지 Vol.27 No.1

교대주기가 다른 두 유리제조업체 3교대 근무자들의 자각증상 비교

정영연,최광서,우극현,한구웅,Jung, Young-Yeon,Choi, Gwang-Seo,Woo, Kuck Hyeun,Han, Gu-Wung 대한예방의학회 1992 예방의학회지 Vol.25 No.4

교대근무자들이 호소하는 생체리듬의 부조화로 인한 일련의 증상들은 개인특성, 작업환경, 교대형태의 영향을 많이 받는다. 따라서 본 연구에서는 개인특성과 작업환경의 영향을 고려하여 교대주기에 따른 근로자들의 자각증상의 차이를 보고자, 작업환경이 같고 교대주기에 있어 2일, 7일인 두 회사의 3교대근로자 182명과 86명을 대상으로 개인 특성 및 자각증상을 설문조사하였다. 결과를 요약하면 다음과 같다. 1. 수면장해증상 6문항 중 '근무 중 피로감을 느낀다', '예민하다'의 두 항목에서 7일주기의 교대근무자에서 증상호소의 빈도가 통계적으로 유의하게 높았으며(P<0.05), 점수화하여 두 군간의 평균을 비교한 결과 7일주기인 군에서 증상점수가 높았다(P<0.01). 2. 1일 평균 6시간의 수면을 기준으로 할 때, 수면시간에 있어서는 두 군간에 유의한 차이가 없었으며, 2일주기인 군에서는 수면시간이 증가함에 따라 장해증상에 현저히 줄었으나 (P<0.05), 7일주기인 군에서는 수면시간에 따른 장해증상의 차이가 없었다. 3. 소화기장해증상 10문항에서는, 7일주기인 군에서 '자주 그렇다'고 호소하는 빈도가 높았으나 통계적인 유의성은 없었으며, 점수화하여 두 군간의 평균을 비교한 결과 역시 7일 주기인 군이 평균점수가 높았으나 통계적으로 유의한 차이는 아니었다. 4. 피로자각증상은 육체적, 정신적 피로 호소율이 7일주기의 교대근무자들에게 현저히 높았으며(P<0.01), 신경감각적 피로 역시 유의한 차이가 있었다(P<0.05). 5. 공분산분석 (ANCOVA)을 통해 개인특성의 영향을 고려한 결과, 교대주기에 파라 수면장해 증상, 육체적, 정신적 피로에 통계적으로 유의한 차이를 보였다(P<0.01). 이상의 결과를 종합해 볼때, 2일주기의 교대근무자들보다 7일주기 교대근무자들이 피로와 수면장해증상 호소가 더 많았다. 따라서 향후 자각증상 뿐 아니라 객관적인 검사를 병행하여 현재 가장 많이 시행되고 있는 7일주기의 교대제에 대한 검토가 필요할 것으로 사료된다. Some circadian rhythms can become disorgnized due to rotating shift work. This lack of organization, termed desynchronization, can produce a group of symptoms such as insomnia, GI disturbance and fatigue among many rotating shift workers. The magnitude of these symptoms are influenced by personal and environmental factors and the patterns of shift work. This study was carried out to investigate the subjective symptoms related to rotational schedules of shift work after personal and environmental factors adjusted. 182 male workers in rapidly rotating shift system and 86 male workers in weekly rotating shift system were conducted the questionnaire on personal factors and subjective sleep, GI and fatigue symptoms. Major findings obtained from this study are as follows: 1. The symptoms of 'feeling tired at work' and 'being irritable' were more frequent in weekly rotating shift workers (P<0.05), and the mean of symptom score was significantly higher in weekly rotating shift workers(P<0.01). 2. According to 6 hours of sleeping which is a definite elevation point of fatigue, there was not a significant difference between two groups in sleeping hours. Among workers in rapidly rotating shift system, the mean of symptom score was significatly higher in workers of less than 6 hours of sleeping(P<0.05), but it was not different among weekly rotating shift workers. 3. The symptoms of GI disturbance were more frequent in weekly rotating shift workers but statistically not significant. 4. The positive rate of mental and physical fatigue symptoms were significantly higher in weekly rotating shift workers(P<0.01) and mental and physical fatigue symptoms were more frequent in them (P<0.01). 5. After the effect of the factors that were significantly different between two groups by $X^2-test$ were controlled, the mean score of sleep disturbance was significantly higher in weekly rotating shift workers (P<0.01) and mental physical fatigue symptoms were more frequent in them (P<0.01). Based on these study results, subjective symptoms were more common in the weekly rotating shift workers. In future, medical examination and laboratory test will be also administered to evaluate a more accurate health outcomes and the review of current shift schedules will be required.