금융지리학의 진화: 마르크스주의 지리정치경제학부터 ‘재정치화’하는 문화경제지리학까지 = Evolving Financial Geography: From the Marxist Geographical Political Economy to the ‘Re-Politicizing’ Cultural Economic Geography

국문 초록 (Abstract)

금융지리학은 시대의 요구에 따라 끊임없이 진화하는 경제지리학의 분과학문이다. 이 논문에서는 오늘날 금융지리학의 모습을 형성한 세 시기의 주요 ‘물결’을 살펴 정리한다. 1990년대 이전까지 금융지리는 분과학문으로서의 정체성을 확립하지 못하고 마르크스주의 지리정치경제학에서 생산자본 축적의 부수적 현상인 것으로 이해되었다(‘제1의 물결’). 1990년대 담론, 실천, 행위주체성을 중시하는 문화적 전환과 포스트구조주의에 영향을 받으며 금융지리학은 하나의 분과학문으로 정립되기 시작했다(‘제2의 물결’). 2000년대 후반 글로벌 금융위기 이후에는 기존 문화경제지리학적 담론의 권력과 정치에 대한 무관심을 성찰하고 변화하려는 노력이 일고 있다. 문화경제지리학 관점의 ‘재정치화’는 신푸코주의에 입각한 통치성과 금융주체화에 대한 분석과 논의를 통해서 진행되고 있다(‘제3의 물결’). 이러한 물결들의 영향력 때문에 오늘날의 금융지리학은 서로 다른 사상적 기반, 분석의 수준과 대상, 주체에 대한 인식, 권력과 정치에 대한 이해, 금융화와 금융의 지리를 설명하는 방식이 공존하며 경합·경쟁하는 학문적 담론과 실천의 장이 되었다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Financial geography is an evolving subdiscipline in economic geography. This paper identifies and reviews three important ‘waves’ constitutive of the current state of financial geography: including the ‘first’ wave before 1990s when finance was regarded as a byproduct of the over-accumulation process in production sphere in the Marxist geographical political economy tradition; the ‘second’ wave in the mid-1990s during which financial geography was firmly established as a subdiscipline, influenced by the cultural turn and poststructuralist thoughts; and the most recent ‘third’ wave after the 2008∼2009 global financial crisis that urged financial geographers to take power and politics more seriously and ‘re-politicize’ with the analytical ideas of governmentality and financial subjectification from a neo-Foucauldian perspective. These waves have helped financial geography become a practice-oriented academic discourse, in which different philosophical thoughts, foci of analytical level and object, renditions of the subject, perceptions of power and politics, and geographies of finance and financialization coexist and also compete and contest one another.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 조선일보, "퇴직연금, 수익률이냐 안정성이냐... 투자기본옵션 논쟁"

2 최재헌, "지리학에서 제도적 접근법에 관한 연구 –한국 금융부문의 제도적 변화를 사례로-" 30 (30): 364-389, 1995

3 한국경제, "작년 비보장 IRP 수익률 13%... 75%는원금 보장형에서 낮잠"

4 류연택, "도시지리학개론" 법문사 255-293, 2020

5 박경환, "글로벌 시대 인문지리학에 있어서 행위자-네트워크 이론(ANT)의 적용 가능성" 한국도시지리학회 17 (17): 57-78, 2014

6 이재열, "글로벌 생산네트워크 담론의 진화: 기업 및 산업 중심 거버넌스 분석을 넘어서" 대한지리학회 51 (51): 667-690, 2016

7 김창현, "공간생산의 금융화 금융지리학의 관점에서" 한국공간환경학회 24 (24): 110-143, 2014

8 MacKinnon D., "경제지리학개론" 사회평론아카데미 2021

9 이희연, "경제지리학" 법문사 2018

10 한국경제, "개인형 퇴직연금 아직도 없으십니까... 여기가 IRP 맛집"

11 Pike, A., "‘Shareholder value’ versus the regions: the closure of the Vaux Brewey in Sunderland" 6 : 201-202, 2006

12 Peck, J., "Workfare States" Guilford Press 2001

13 Hall, S., "What counts? Exploring the production of quantitative financial narratives in London ‘s corporate finance industry" 6 (6): 661-678, 2006

14 이재열, "Urban Community as a Contested Practice: A Gap between Ordinary Practices and Civic Advocacy Discourse" 대한지리학회 51 (51): 269-281, 2016

15 Lai, K. P., "Unpacking financial subjectivities:Intimacies, governance and socioeconomic practices in financialization" 35 (35): 913-932, 2017

16 Smith, N., "Uneven Development" University of Georgia Press 1990

17 Maurer, B., "Uncanny exchanges: the possibilities of ‘making change’ with alternative monetary forms" 21 (21): 317-340, 2003

18 Yeung, H. W. C., "Toward a dynamic theory of global production networks" 91 (91): 29-58, 2015

19 Jones, A., "Theorizing practice in economic geography: Foundations, challenges, and possibilities" 35 (35): 366-392, 2011

20 Allen, J., "The whereabout of power: politics, government and space" 86 (86): 19-32, 2004

21 Boddy, M. J., "The structure of mortgage finance:Building societies and the British social formation" 1 : 58-71, 1976

22 Williams, P., "The role of institutions in the inner London Housing market: The case of Islington" 1 (1): 72-82, 1976

23 Fryer, D. W., "The political geography of international lending by private banks" 12 : 413-432, 1987

24 Zook, M., "The microgeographies of global finance: High-Frequency trading and the construction of inequality" 49 (49): 121-140, 2017

25 Harvey, D., "The geographies of critical geography" 31 (31): 409-412, 2006

26 Coppock, S., "The everyday geographies of financialization:Impacts, subjects and alternatives" 6 (6): 479-500, 2013

27 Barnett, C., "The consolations of “neoliberalism”" 36 (36): 7-12, 2005

28 Clark G L.., "The Sociology of Financial Markets" Oxford University Press 229-249, 2005

29 Clark, G., "The Routledge Handbook of Financial Geography" Routledge 286-307, 2020

30 Clark, G., "The Routledge Handbook of Financial Geography" Routledge 263-285, 2020

31 Bond, P., "The Routledge Handbook of Financial Geography" Routledge 56-83, 2020

32 Langley, P., "The Routledge Handbook of Financial Geography" Routledge 328-351, 2020

33 Knox-Hayes, J., "The Routledge Handbook of Financial Geography" Routledge 2020

34 Clark, G. L., "The New Oxford Handbook of Economic Geography" Oxford University Press 2018

35 Harvey, D., "The New Imperialism" Oxford University Press 2003

36 Harvey, D., "The Limits to Capital" Blackwell 1982

37 Foucault, M., "The Foucault Effect:Studies in Governmentality" The University of Chicago Press 87-104, 1991

38 Langley, P., "The Everyday Life of Global Finance: Saving and Borrowing in Anglo-America" Oxford University Press 2008

39 Pryke, M., "Take an issue: cultural economy and finance" 36 (36): 339-354, 2007

40 Harvey, D., "Social Justice and the City" Edward Arnold 1973

41 Jones, J. P., "Situating flatness" 32 (32): 264-276, 2007

42 Thrift, N., "Refiguring the economic in economic geography" 20 (20): 311-337, 1996

43 Latour, B., "Reassembling the Social" Oxford University Press 2005

44 Jones, A., "Practice and economic geography" 4 (4): 303-319, 2010

45 Callon, M., "Peripheral vision: Market as calculative collective devices" 26 (26): 1229-1250, 2005

46 Clark G., "Performing finance:the industry, the media and its image" 11 (11): 289-310, 2004

47 Zaloom, C., "Out of the Pits: Traders and Technology from Chicago to London" Chicago University Press 2006

48 Amin, A., "On being political" 32 (32): 112-115, 2007

49 Larner, W., "Neolibrealism?" 21 (21): 509-512, 2003

50 Clark, G. L., "Myopia and the global financial crisis:Context-specific reasoning, market structure, and institutional governance" 1 (1): 4-25, 2011

51 Leyshon, A., "Money/Space: Geographies of Monetary Transformation" Routledge 1997

52 Corbridge, S., "Money, Power, Space" Blackwell 1994

53 Thrift, N., "Money, Power, Space" Blackwel 327-355, 1994

54 Laulajainen, R., "Money and the space economy" 81 (81): 127-129, 1999

55 Martin, R., "Money and the Space Economy" Wiley 1999

56 Ho, K., "Liquidated: An Ethnography of Wall Street" Duke University Press 2009

57 Pollard, J., "Islamic banking and finance:Postcolonial political economy and the decentring of economic geography" 32 : 313-330, 2007

58 Kish, Z., "Investing for profit, investing for impact: Moral performances in agricultural investment projects" 50 (50): 569-588, 2018

59 헤럴드경제, "IRP, 연령별⋅소득수준별 세제혜택 차등적용 해야"

60 Tickell, A., "Handbook of Cultural Geography" SAGE 116-130, 2003

61 Kear, M., "Governing homo subprimicus: Beyond financial citizenship, exclusion, and rights" 45 (45): 926-946, 2013

62 Knorr Cetina, K., "Global microstructures:the virtual societies of financial markets" 107 (107): 905-950, 2002

63 Olds, K., "Global Assemblage" Blackwell 270-290, 2005

64 Jones, A., "Geographies of production I: Relationality revisited and the ‘practice shift’ in economic geography" 38 (38): 605-615, 2014

65 Leyshon, A., "Geographies of money and finance III" 22 (22): 433-446, 1998

66 Hall, S., "Geographies of money and finance II:Financialization and financial subjects" 36 (36): 403-441, 2012

67 Leyshon, A., "Geographies of money and finance II" 21 (21): 381-392, 1997

68 Hall, S., "Geographies of money and finance I:Cultural economy, politics and place" 35 (35): 234-245, 2010

69 Leyshon, A., "Geographies of money and finance I" 19 (19): 531-543, 1995

70 Leyshon, A., "Geographies of financial exclusion: Financial abandonment in Britain and the United States" 20 (20): 312-341, 1995

71 Christophers, B., "Geographies of finance III: Regulation and ‘after-crisis’ financial futures" 40 (40): 138-148, 2016

72 Christophers, B., "Geographies of finance II: Crisis, space and political-economic transformation" 39 (39): 205-213, 2015

73 Christophers, B., "Geographies of finance I: Historical geographies of the crisis-ridden past" 38 (38): 285-293, 2014

74 McDowell, L., "Geographies of Economies" Arnold 118-129, 1997

75 Sheppard, E., "Geographical political economy" 11 (11): 319-331, 2011

76 Keenan, L., "Financialization, securitization, and the decline of pubs in Britain" 20 (20): 1293-1311, 2020

77 Aalbers, M. B., "Financial geography: Introduction to the virtual issue" 40 (40): 300-305, 2015

78 Aalbers, M. B., "Financial geography III: The financialization of the city" 44 (44): 595-607, 2020

79 Aalbers, M. B., "Financial geography II: Financial geographies of housing and real estate" 43 (43): 376-387, 2019

80 Aalbers, M. B., "Financial geography I: Geographies of tax" 42 (42): 916-927, 2018

81 Leyshon, A., "Financial exclusion and the geography of bank and building society closure in Britain" 33 (33): 447-465, 2008

82 Castree, N., "Economy and culture are dead! Long live economy and culture!" 28 (28): 204-226, 2004

83 Coe, N. M., "Economic Geography: A Contemporary Introduction" Wiley 2020

84 Wyly, E., "Cartographies of race and class: Mapping the class-monopoly rents of American subprime mortgage capital" 33 (33): 332-354, 2009

85 McDowell, L., "Capital culture revisited: Sex, testoster one and the city" 34 (34): 652-658, 2010

86 Williams, P., "Building societies and the inner city" 3 (3): 23-34, 1978

87 Butler, J., "Bodies that Matter" Routledge 1993

88 Anderson, B., "Assemblage and geography" 43 (43): 124-127, 2011

89 Muniesa, F., "An introduction to market devices" 55 (55): 1-12, 2007

90 Pryke, M., "An international city going ‘global’: Spatial change in the city of London" 9 (9): 197-222, 1991

91 Leyshon, A., "A Companion to Economic Geography" Blackwell 2000