A comparison study on high-order bounded schemes:Flow of PTT-linear fluid in a lid-driven square cavity

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In this computational study, the convergence, stability and order of accuracy of several different numerical schemes are assessed and compared. All of the schemes considered were developed using a normalized variable diagram. Two test cases are considered: (1) two-dimensional steady incompressible laminar flow of a Newtonian fluid in a square lid-driven cavity; and (2) creeping flow of a PTT-linear fluid in a lid-driven square cavity. The governing equations are discretized to varying degrees of refinement using uniform grids, and solved by using the finite volume technique. The momentum interpolation method (MIM) is employed to evaluate the face velocity. Coupled mass and momentum conservation equations are solved through an iterative SIMPLE (Semi-Implicit Method for Pressure-Linked Equation) algorithm. Among the higher-order and bounded schemes considered in the present study, only the CLAM, COPLA, CUBISTA, NOTABLE, SMART and WACEB schemes provide a steady converged solution to the prescribed tolerance of 110-5 at all studied Weissenberg (We) numbers, using a very fine mesh structure. It is found that the CLAM, COPLA, CUBISTA, SMART and WACEB schemes provide about the same order of accuracy that is slightly higher than that of the NOTABLE scheme at low and high Weissenberg numbers. Moreover, flow structures formed in the cavity, i.e. primary vortex, are captured accurately up to We = 5 by all converged schemes.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Wei, J. J., "new general convective boundness criterion" 49 : 585-598, 2006

2 Leonard, B. P., "Why you should not use ‘Hybrid’, ‘Power- Law’ or related exponential schemes for convective modeling: there are much better alternatives" 20 : 421-442, 1995

3 Warming, R. F., "Upwind second-order difference schemes and applications in aerodynamic flows" 14 : 1241-1249, 1976

4 Van Leer, B., "Towards the ultimate conservation difference scheme. V. A second-order sequel to Godunov’s Method" 32 : 101-136, 1979

5 Van Leer, B., "Towards the ultimate conservation difference scheme. II. Monotonicity and conservation combined in second- order scheme" 14 : 361-370, 1974

6 Marchi, C. H., "The lid-driven square cavity flow: Numerical solution with a 1024x1024 grid" 31 : 186-198, 2009

7 Leonard, B. P., "The ULTIMATE conservative difference scheme applied to unsteady one-dimensional advection" 88 : 17-74, 1991

8 Leonard, B. P., "Simple high-accuracy resolution program for convective modeling of discontinuities" 8 : 1291-1318, 1988

9 Roache, P. J., "Quantification of uncertainty in computational fluid dynamics" 29 : 123-160, 1997

10 Ng, K. C., "Parametric study of an improved GAMMA differencing scheme based on normalized variable formulation for low-speed flow with artificial compressibility technique" 50 : 561-584, 2006

11 Song, B., "On a higher-order bounded discretization scheme" 32 : 881-897, 2000

12 Patankar, S. V., "Numerical Heat Transfer and Fluid Flow" McGraw-Hill 1980

13 Zijlema, M., "Higher-order flux-limiting schemes for the finite volume computation of incompressible flow" 9 : 89-109, 1998

14 Ng, K. C., "Higher-order bounded differencing schemes for compressible and incompressible flows" 53 : 57-80, 2007

15 Chakravarthy, S. R., "High-resolution of the OSHER upwind scheme for the Euler equations" 21 : 1241-1248, 1983

16 Sweby, P. K., "High resolution schemes using flux limiters for hyperbolic conservation laws" 21 : 995-1011, 1984

17 Harten, A., "High resolution schemes for hyperbolic conservation laws" 49 : 357-393, 1983

18 Jasak, H., "High resolution NVD differencing scheme for arbitrarily unstructured meshes" 31 : 431-449, 1999

19 Erturk, E., "Fourth order compact formulation of Navier-Stokes equations and driven cavity flow at high Reynolds numbers" 50 : 421-436, 2006

20 Yapici, K., "Finite volume simulation of viscoelastic laminar flow in a lid-driven cavity" 164 : 51-65, 2009

21 Alves, M. A., "Effect of a high-resolution differencing scheme on finite-volume predictions of viscoelastic flows" 93 : 287-314, 2000

22 Schreiber, R., "Driven cavity flows by efficient numerical techniques" 49 : 310-333, 1983

23 Erturk, E., "Discussion on driven cavity flow" 60 : 275-294, 2009

24 Gaskell, P. H., "Curvature-compensated convective tansport: SMART, a new boundedness preserving transport algorithm" 8 : 617-641, 1988

25 Nacer, B., "Contribution to the improvement of the QUICK scheme for the resolution of the convection-diffusion problems" 43 : 1075-1085, 2007

26 Przulj, V., "Bounded convection schemes for unstructured grids" 2001

27 Botella, O., "Benchmark spectral results on the lid-driven cavity flow" 27 (27): 421-433, 1998

28 Cruz, D. O. A., "Analytical solution for fully developed laminar flow of some viscoelastic liquids with a Newtonian solvent contribution" 132 : 28-35, 2005

29 Versteeg, H. K., "An introduction to computational fluid dynamics: The finite volume method" Prentice Hall 1995

30 Pascau, A., "A well-behaved scheme to model strong convection in general transport equation" 5 : 75-87, 1995

31 Leonard, B. P., "A stable and accurate convective modeling procedure based on quadratic interpolation" 19 : 59-98, 1979

32 Darwish, M. S., "A new high-resolution scheme based on the normalized variable formulation" 24 : 353-373, 1993

33 Wei, J. J., "A new high-order-accurate and bounded scheme for incompressible flow" 43 : 19-41, 2003

34 Phan-Thien, N., "A new constitutive equation derived from network theory" 2 : 353-365, 1977

35 Zhu, J., "A low dispersion and bounded convection scheme" 92 : 225-232, 1991

36 Choi, S. K., "A high resolution and bounded convection scheme" 9 : 240-250, 1995

37 Khosla, P. K., "A diagonally dominant second order accurate implicit scheme" 2 : 207-209, 1974

38 Alves, M. A., "A convergent and universally bounded interpolation scheme for the treatment of advection" 4 : 47-75, 2003

39 Hayase, T., "A consistently formulated quick scheme for fast and stable convergence using finite-volume iterative calculation procedures" 98 : 108-118, 1992

40 Coelho, P. J., "A comparison of spatial discretization schemes for differential solution methods of the radiative transfer equation" 109 : 189-200, 2008

41 Patankar, S. V., "A calculation procedure for heat, mass and momentum transfer in three-dimensional parabolic flows" 15 : 1787-1806, 1972