형식 및 질적요소 체계분석을 통한 공동주택 하자감정서의 개선방안 = Improvement on Defect Consulting Report in Apartment Building by Analyzing on Formal Index and Quantitative Index

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The main issue of defect dispute is consulting, reviewing, and finally judging as an arbiter. A defect consulting isrepresented a defect consulting report, but a business custom and a standard of judgment are different each consultants,and have many problems. This study reviews literature studies and institutional researches, set up a research structure. it has 7 indexes that 5 indexes are formal indexes, and the other are qualitative indexed. As a result of case study,formal indexes are respect on the whole. However, each appraiser has different ideas, and, is expected to delay on fixinga construction lawsuit practice. This study suggests to improve a defect consulting report, it is followed. In formal part,suggested to change configuration is adjusted and integrated similar items. In qualitative part, an evaluation system forappraiser and an education program for engineers is suggested.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

공동주택의 하자감정과 관련된 다양한 문제점에 대한개선을 하기 위하여, 본 연구에서는 선행연구와 관련기준등을 분석하여 하자감정서의 분석체계를 마련하였다. 이를 활용하여 하자감정서 24건을 분석하였고 형식 요소와질적 요소를 검토한 결과, 형식 요소의 경우 구성을 다소변경하는 수준으로 손쉬운 대안을 제안하였다. 질적 요소를 분석한 결과, 감정인에 대한 평가제도와 참여기술자에대한 전문교육제도의 마련을 통해 하자감정의 내실화를강화할 수 있을 것으로 기대된다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 최정현, "공동주택 하자분쟁의 법률적 쟁점사항 분석" 대한건축학회 25 (25): 145-153, 2009

2 박준모, "공동주택 하자분쟁 조정제도의 활성화 방안 - 기술적 쟁점사항에 대한 대응전략을 중심으로 -" 한국건축시공학회 11 (11): 208-220, 2011

3 Yoon JY, "Improvement for optimizing and specializing on deciding of construction lawsuit" 114 : 6-46, 2009

4 Kim BS, "Improvement Plan on Appraisal System of Defect Disputes about Cracks on Apartment Buildings" 185-186, 2011

5 "Construction consulting report" Cheongju district court in Youngdong part 2008

6 "Construction consulting report" Seoul central district court 2008

7 "Construction consulting report" Seoul central district court 2008

8 "Construction consulting report" Seoul central district court 2008

9 "Construction consulting report" Seoul central district court 2008

10 "Construction consulting report" Seoul central district court 2008

11 "Construction consulting report" Suwon district court in Sungnam part 2008

12 "Construction consulting report" Suwon district court in Sungnam part 2008

13 "Construction consulting report" Suwon district court in Sungnam part 2008

14 "Construction consulting report" Seoul high court 2008

15 "Construction consulting report" Seoul central district court 2008

16 "Construction consulting report" Seoul central district court 2008

17 "Construction consulting report" Seoul central district court 2008

18 "Construction consulting report" Suwon district court in Sungnam part 2008

19 "Construction consulting report" Suwon district court in Sungnam part 2008

20 "Construction consulting report" Incheon district court in Bucheon part 2008

21 Society for construction lawsuit in seoul central district court, "Construction Lawsuit Practice" Society for construction lawsuit in seoul central district court 248-, 2011

22 Seoul south district court, "Case-No.2007gahap10079"

23 서덕석, "Analysis of Consulting Reports on Defect Disputes in Apartment Building" 한국건축시공학회 13 (13): 498-505, 2013

24 Korean Institute of Construction Engineering and Management, "A research for judged standard, investigated method and estimated costing of defect in apartment building" Korean Institute of Construction Engineering and Management 460-, 2012

25 Yoo BH, "A basic process of construction consulting and consulting case of ice thermal storage system" 36 (36): 15-22, 2007

26 Lee SC, "A Study on Solution for Improvement and Case Analysis of Inspective Business in Defects of Apartment Buildings" Kyungnam University 2011