항암제와 한약재의 병용투여 시 암세포 증식억제 효과에 대한 국내 실험연구 문헌고찰 = A Review on Experimental Research about Anticancer Drug Combined Treatment with Herbal Medicine for Killing or Inhibiting Proliferation of Cancer cells in Korea.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Objective : In this study, we searched the experimental research about combined treatment of anticancer drug and herbal medicine for killing or inhibiting proliferation of Cancer cells searched in OASIS and KISS. This study aimed to analyze the experimental research paper about anticancer drug combined treatment with herbal medicine. Methods : We collected the research paper including killing or inhibiting proliferation of Cancer cells in OASIS and KISS using keyword anticancer drug with herbal medicine, tumor suppressor with herbal medicine, inhibition of Cancer with herbal medicine and combined treatment with herbal medicine. Assorting by cancer cells, we analyzed experimental results cancer cell viability, anticancer drug dosage, tumor weight and survival rate. Also, we checked the effects of herbal medicine on cancer and additive effect reducing side effect of anticancer drug. Results : Total 45 studies were selected. 38 studies reported combined treatment of anticancer drug and herbal medicine was more effective than only anticancer drug. The death of cancer cells was synergistically induced by the cotreatment of anticancer drug and herb extracts. The studies suggest that the cotreatment of anticancer drug and herb extracts could reduce side effect of anticancer drug. In addition, some studies reported cotreatment mechanism like apoptotic death signal processes. In combined treatment of anticancer drug and herb extracts, The expression of Fas/Fas L, Bax, Bcl2, Caspase-3 etc.. was markedly increased in cancer cells. Conclusions : Our results suggest that anticancer drug combined treatment with herbal medicine could be efficient for killing or inhibiting proliferation of cancer cells. However, this paper had some limitation as follows: First, collected studies have been published only for korean journal. Second, results of research and effects of combined treatment are not collected objectively. To solve these problems, more objective and balanced studies should be performed.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김진현, "한약-양약 병용 투여에 관한 논문 동향 분석" 대한예방한의학회 13 (13): 1-18, 2009

2 이병호, "폐암세포주 H-157에서 加減增液湯과 As2O3의 병용처리에 의한 抗腫瘍效果" 대한한의학회 25 (25): 191-202, 2004

3 조해중, "자궁경부암 세포주에서 활성산소종의 영향에 의한 Apoptosis를 통하여 세포성장을 억제하는 Cisplatin과 Berberine의 상승효과" 한의병리학회 21 (21): 992-997, 2007

4 송봉길, "인간 폐암세포주 H-460세포에서 加減十全大補湯과 As2O3의 병용처리에 의한 항종양 증진효과" 한의병리학회 18 (18): 1089-1097, 2004

5 백은기, "인간 간암세포주 HepG2에서 八珍抗癌丹과 adriamycin의 병용처리에 의한 抗腫瘍 효과" 한의병리학회 17 (17): 1243-1250, 2003

6 김춘배, "암 환자의 한약, 양약 병용 투여" 대한한의학회 28 (28): 205-212, 2007

7 은재순, "사향과 항암제 Mitomycin C의 병용효과" 한의병리학회 17 (17): 1404-1408, 2003

8 전정회, "黃？와 Chlorambucil 倂用이 P388D1 白血病 細胞 및 擔癌생쥐에 미치는 影響" 대한한방내과학회 26 (26): 291-301, 2005

9 신민규, "順氣和中湯과 Doxorubicin의 병용이 MKN-45의 항암효과에 미치는 영향" 대한한의학회 25 (25): 98-109, 2004

10 강연이, "韓醫學의 抗腫瘍 免疫治療에 관한 연구-1990年 以後 發表된 實驗論文을 中心으로-" 한의병리학회 17 (17): 1-24, 2003

11 이윤희, "補中益氣合大七氣湯과 Doxorubicin의 병용이 MKN-45의 항암효과에 미치는 영향" 대한한방내과학회 25 (25): 92-105, 2004

12 이윤희, "補中益氣合大七氣湯과 Doxorubicin의 병용이 Colon-26의 항암효과에 미치는 영향" 대한한의학회 25 (25): 9-21, 2004

13 김진철, "苦參이 항암제 cisplatin의 膵·心臟 부작용 감소에 미치는 영향" 한의병리학회 19 (19): 945-949, 2005

14 김진철, "苦參이 抗癌劑 cisplatin의 肝？腎臟 副作用 減少에 미치는 影響" 경락경혈학회 22 (22): 165-174, 2005

15 김주연, "生地黃이 子宮頸部癌細胞(HeLa cell)에 미치는 影響" 대한한방부인과학회 19 (19): 69-80, 2006

16 안훈모, "淸肺瀉肝湯과 YKK012의 항암제 CPT-11과 병용투여 시 대장암 성장억제에 미치는 효과" 대한본초학회 30 (30): 33-42, 2015

17 신학수, "定志丸과 시스플라틴의 神經膠芽細胞腫에 對한 細胞枯死 機轉硏究" 대한한의학회 26 (26): 1-12, 2005

18 남주영, "半枝蓮과 항암제 병용 투여에 의한 암세포 성장 저해에 관한 연구" 대한한방부인과학회 22 (22): 125-139, 2009

19 강문여, "仙傳化毒湯이 癌細胞 및 免疫細胞 增殖에 미치는 實驗的 效果- 항암제 병용효과를 중심으로 -" 대한한방안이비인후피부과학회 18 (18): 104-115, 2005

20 Seong HJ, "experimental Studies on the Kidney Cytotoxicity of Mouse by cisplatin and Liver Function of Sophora flavescens Aiton Effects" 14 (14): 167-172, 2001

21 Moon G, "experimental Studies on the Anti-tumor Effects of Bujeonghangam-tang" 11 (11): 16-26, 1997

22 Kim SJ, "experimental Studies on Antitumor Effects of Paljintanghabhwajuckhwan" 21 (21): 65-73, 2000

23 Jeong DH, "experimental Effects of Taklihwangkitang on the anti-cancer and Immuno-action" 15 (15): 118-131, 2002

24 Lee HW, "experimental Effects of Bangdoktang on the anti-cancer and Immuno-action" 15 (15): 263-281, 1994

25 Jeon BH, "The Cytotoxicity of Methanol extract of Radix Codonopsitis and mitomycin C" 7 (7): 5-10, 1997

26 Eun JS, "The Combined Effects of n-BuOH Fraction of Ulmi Cortex and Anticancer Drugs on Cancer Cell Lines" 25 (25): 144-152, 1994

27 Cho YD, "The Combined Effect of Banhyun-hwan and Anticancer Drug in Human Cervical Carcinoma HeLa cells" 8 (8): 49-62, 1995

28 Kim DH, "The Anti-tumor activity of Taraxaci Herba in Liver cancer cells and The Combined Effect of Taraxaci Herba and Anti-cancer drug" 16 (16): 386-413, 1995

29 Shin MK, "The Anti-tumor Effect of Soonkiwhajungtang with doxorubicin in Colon-26" 12 (12): 119-137, 2004

30 Song HJ, "The Anti-tumor Effect of Herba Artemisiae Capillaris in Liver cancer cells and S-180" 10 : 129-162, 1995

31 Lee YH, "The Anti-tumor Effect of Bojungikkeehapdaechilkitang with doxorubicin in 3LL" 12 (12): 131-148, 2004

32 Lee BG, "Study on Synergistic Antitumor Effect of Combination with adriamycin and Palginhonhapwhajucwhan" 21 (21): 443-452, 2000

33 Kim SM, "Study on Apoptosis Inducement of Human Glioblastoma Cells by SaengMaecSan" 24 (24): 870-881, 2003

34 Ko YC, "Study on Anticancer Mechanism of Gilkyeungtang in Lung Cancer Cells" 9 (9): 94-114, 2003

35 Kim TW, "Studies on the effects of Sojeokbaekchoolsan on the bleomycin induced pulmonary fibrosis and the anti-tumor activity" 5 (5): 77-101, 1999

36 Ahn MS, "Studies on the combined Effect of Several Combined Preparation of Crude Drugs and mitomycin C(I)" 22 (22): 158-170, 1992

37 Kim BS, "Statistical Method for Testing Synergism among Several Compounds" 6 (6): 383-391, 1993

38 Wing Lam, "PHY906(KD018), an adjuvant based on a 1800-year-old Chinese medicine, enhanced the anti-tumor activity of Sorafenib by changing the tumor microenvironment" 5 : 9384-, 2015

39 National Cancer Information Center., "Major Cancer Death Rate"

40 Koreanoncology Textbook Publish Committee., "Integrative Oncology of Korean Medicine" Kunja Publisher 17-18, 2013

41 Donald Abrams, "Integrative Oncology" E public 19-, 2009

42 Donald Abrams, "Integrative Oncology" E public 276-, 2009

43 Shim SH, "Influences on the anticancer and inhibitive effects of the secondary effects by Anticarcinogen of Shibyukmiyoukieum" 15 (15): 302-314, 2002

44 Choi SH, "Immunopotentiating Effects and Antitumor activities of Sipjundaebo-tang" 11 (11): 257-238, 2002

45 Muhammad Wasif Saif, "First-in-human Phase II trial of the Botanical Formulation PHY906 with Capecitabine as Second-line Therapy in Patients with Advanced Pancreatic Cancer" 73 (73): 373-380, 2014

46 Park KS, "Effects of Wekyungtang and KamiWekyungtang on Cytotoxicity of A549 cells and Antitumor Effect of S-180" 10 : 217-245, 1995

47 Kim HS, "Effects of Wekyungtang and Kami-Wekyungtang on Pulmonary Tumor Cells and the Changes of Tissues" 10 : 217-245, 1995

48 Cho HJ, "Effects of Soyosangamibang on antitumor chemotherapy and lysosomal enzymes of tumor cell" 18 (18): 119-136, 1997

49 Lee DJ, "Effects of Sipjeondaebotanggamibang on Anti-tumor Chemotherapeutic Cytotoxicity and Lysosomal Enzymes of Tumor cell" 7 (7): 116-123, 1997

50 Jeon BH., "Effects of Methanol extract of Radix Astragali on Anti-tumor Chemotherapeutic Cytotoxicity" 12 (12): 55-59, 1998

51 Jeon SH, "Effects of Jukyeopseokgo-tanggagambang on Anti-tumor Chemotherapeutic Cytotoxicity and Lysosomal Enzymes of Tumor cell" 3 (3): 149-167, 1997

52 Kim GT, "Effects of Gamihagochosan on Anti-tumor Cytotoxicity and Tumor cell" 18 (18): 175-190, 1997

53 Jeong HW, "Effects of Flos Lonicerae and Herba Houtluynrae on Human Cancer Cells" 10 (10): 126-132, 1996

54 Nam WY, "Effects of Ethanol extract of Radix Salviaemetiorrhizae on Anti-tumor Chemotherapeutic Cytotoxicity such as mitomycin C" 11 (11): 113-117, 1997

55 Jeong HW, "Cytotoxic Effects of Dictamni Cortex Radicis and Manitis Squama on Human Cancer Cells" 11 (11): 58-64, 1997

56 National Cancer Information Center., "Cure Principle"

57 YANG YF, "Cohort study on the effect of a combined treatment of traditional Chinese medicine and Western medicine on the relapse and metastasis of 222 patients with stage II and III colorectal cancer after radical operation" 14 (14): 251-256, 2008

58 National Cancer Information Center., "Cancer Statistics"

59 Son GH, "Antitumor Activity of Bupleuri Radix and Artemisiae capillaris Herba and Synergistic Effect with Anticancer Drugs" 16 (16): 414-432, 1995

60 National Cancer Information Center., "Anti-cancer Chemotherapy"

61 Liao YH, "Adjunctive traditional Chinese medicine therapy improves survival of liver cancer patients" 35 (35): 595-602, 2015

62 National Cancer Information Center., "10 years Survival Rate"