디지털 치열 모형에서 악궁 관계 지표 측정의 타당성 = Validity of Arch Relationship Measurements in Digital Dental Models

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The aim of the present study is to evaluate the validity of orthodontic measurements including tooth width, Bolton ratio, overjet and overbite on the digital dental models.
Dental models of the subjects aged 12 to 18 were obtained in 3 different forms, which were conventional stone model, digital model created with Freedom HD model scanner, and digital model produced with CS3600 intraoral scanner. After measurements were made on the models, reliability and reproducibility of the measurements were evaluated by using intraclass correlation coefficient, while validity was assessed with paired t-test.
As a result, significant reliability and reproducibility were verified, with intraclass correlation coefficient exceeding 0.750 in all groups. Measurements of the model scanned group showed an adequate validity in overall and anterior Bolton ratio, overjet, and overbite. Intraoral scanned models showed an adequate validity in anterior Bolton ratio, and overjet.
Measurement on intraoral scanned digital models can be considered as an alternative for young children who have difficulty in taking impression. Furthermore, careful considerations on measurement error should be made in clinical situations.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Whetten JL, "Variations in orthodontic treatment planning decisions of Class II patients between virtual 3-dimensional models and traditional plaster study models" 130 : 485-491, 2006

2 Naidu D, "Validity, reliability, and reproducibility of the iOC intraoral scanner : a comparison of tooth widths and Bolton ratios" 144 : 304-310, 2013

3 Stevens DR, "Validity, reliability, and reproducibility of plaster vs digital study models : comparison of peer assessment rating and Bolton analysis and their constituent measurements" 129 : 794-803, 2006

4 Wiranto MG, "Validity, reliability, and reproducibility of linear measurements on digital models obtained from intraoral and cone-beam computed tomography scans of alginate impressions" 143 : 140-147, 2013

5 Burhardt L, "Treatment comfort, time perception, and preference for conventional and digital impression techniques : A comparative study in young patients" 150 : 261-267, 2016

6 Othman SA, "Tooth-size discrepancy and Bolton’s ratios : a literature review" 33 : 45-51, 2006

7 Davidowitz G, "The use of CAD/CAM in dentistry" 55 : 559-570, 2011

8 Roberts CT, "The design and analysis of reliability studies for the use of epidemiological and audit indices in orthodontics" 24 : 139-147, 1997

9 Foster TD, "The assessment of occlusal features for public health planning purposes" 69 : 83-90, 1976

10 Houston WJ, "The analysis of errors in orthodontic measurements" 83 : 382-390, 1983

11 de Waard O, "Reproducibility and accuracy of linear measurements on dental models derived from cone-beam computed tomography compared with digital dental casts" 146 : 328-336, 2014

12 Shellhart WC, "Reliability of the Bolton tooth-size analysis when applied to crowded dentitions" 65 : 327-334, 1995

13 Sharma R, "Prevalence of tooth size discrepancy among North Indian orthodontic patients" 2 : 170-175, 2011

14 Flügge TV, "Precision of intraoral digital dental impressions with iTero and extraoral digitization with the iTero and a model scanner" 144 : 471-478, 2013

15 Kinaan BK, "Overjet and overbite distribution and correlation : a comparative epidemiological English-Iraqi study" 13 : 79-86, 1986

16 Fleming PS, "Orthodontic measurements on digital study models compared with plaster models : a systematic review" 14 : 1-16, 2011

17 Beyron HL, "Occlusal changes in adult dentition" 48 : 674-686, 1954

18 Santoro M, "Mesiodistal crown dimensions and tooth size discrepancy of the permanent dentition of Dominican Americans" 70 : 303-307, 2000

19 Guyatt G, "Measuring change over time : assessing the usefulness of evaluative instruments" 40 : 171-178, 1987

20 Hacker T, "Impact of procedures during prosthodontic treatment on patients’ perceived burdens" 43 : 51-57, 2015

21 Park GH, "Feasibility of using an intraoral scanner for a complete-arch digital scan" 121 : 803-810, 2019

22 Renne W, "Evaluation of the accuracy of 7 digital scanners : An in vitro analysis based on 3-dimensional comparisons" 118 : 36-42, 2017

23 Abizadeh N, "Digital versus plaster study models : how accurate and reproducible are they?" 39 : 151-159, 2012

24 Yilmaz H, "Digital versus conventional impression method in children : Comfort, preference and time" 29 : 728-735, 2019

25 Plooij JM, "Digital three-dimensional image fusion processes for planning and evaluating orthodontics and orthognathic surgery. A systematic review" 40 : 341-352, 2011

26 Rossini G, "Diagnostic accuracy and measurement sensitivity of digital models for orthodontic purposes : A systematic review" 149 : 161-170, 2016

27 Hugo Lambert ; Jean-Cédric Durand ; Bruno Jacquot ; Michel Fages, "Dental biomaterials for chairside CAD/CAM: State of the art" 대한치과보철학회 9 (9): 486-495, 2017

28 Rekow ED, "Dental CAD-CAM systems. What is the state of the art?" 122 : 42-48, 1991

29 Kim J, "Comparison of experience curves between two 3-dimensional intraoral scanners" 116 : 221-230, 2016

30 Burzynski JA, "Comparison of digital intraoral scanners and alginate impressions : Time and patient satisfaction" 153 : 534-541, 2018

31 Lim JH, "Comparison of digital intraoral scanner reproducibility and image trueness considering repetitive experience" 119 : 225-232, 2018

32 Nagy Z, "Comparing the trueness of seven intraoral scanners and a physical impression on dentate human maxilla by a novel method" 20 : 97-, 2020

33 Grünheid T, "Clinical use of a direct chairside oral scanner : an assessment of accuracy, time, and patient acceptance" 146 : 673-682, 2014

34 Favaretto M, "Big Data and Digitalization in Dentistry : A Systematic Review of the Ethical Issues" 17 : 2495-, 2020

35 Rheude B, "An evaluation of the use of digital study models in orthodontic diagnosis and treatment planning" 75 : 300-304, 2005

36 Camardella LT, "Accuracy and reproducibility of measurements on plaster models and digital models created using an intraoral scanner" 78 : 211-220, 2017

37 Sousa MV, "Accuracy and reproducibility of 3-dimensional digital model measurements" 142 : 269-273, 2012