대학에서의 팀 학습 활동에 대한 학습자의 평가 = Learners' Evaluation on Team Learning Activities in College Education

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this study was to understand learners' reactions toward team learning activities in college education. Students' evaluations on team learning activities were collected from four universities in Seoul, Korea in December, 2009. The items included in the student evaluation were evaluations on ① overall satisfaction toward the class, ② instructional methods, ③ instructor's enthusiasm, ④ instructional materials, ⑤ task load, ⑥ test and assignments, ⑦ instructor's attention to learners, ⑧ the level of motivation, and ⑨ the level of knowledge acquisition. The results demonstrated that the students' evaluations on team learning activities showed a significant difference in years of schooling when it came to overall satisfaction toward class and the level of motivation. The students' evaluation also revealed that there was a significant difference in instructional materials and the level of motivation according to the class contents. By the class size, instructor's enthusiasm, instructional materials, and the level of motivation showed a significant difference. Findings were discussed in terms of pedagogical implications on team learning activities in college education.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

이 연구는 최근 증가하고 있는 대학의 팀 학습 활동에 대한 학습자의 반응을 알아보는 것을 목적으로 하였다. 이를 위하여 팀 학습 활동에 관련된 이론과 선행연구를 검토하였고, 2009년 12월 서울 소재 4개 대학의 213명의 재학생으로부터 설문에 대한 응답을 얻었다. 팀 학습 활동에 대한 학습자의 반응은 ① 수업에 대한 전반적인 호감도, ② 수업의 체계성, ③ 교수자의 열의, ④ 수업 자료의 적절성, ⑤ 학습량의 증가 여부, ⑥ 시험과 과제물의 적절성, ⑦ 교수자의 학생에 대한 관심, ⑧ 학습의욕 증대 여부, ⑨ 지식습득 증대 여부가 학년, 수업내용, 수업규모에 따라 차이가 있는지를 통하여 평가하였다. 연구 결과, 학년에 따라 팀 학습 활동을 하는 수업에 대한 전반적인 호감도와 학습의욕 증대 여부에 차이를 보였고, 수업 내용에 따라 수업의 체계성과 학습의욕 증대 여부에 차이가 나타났다. 수업의 규모에 따라 수업에 대한 교수자의 열의, 시험 및 과제물의 적절성, 그리고 학습의욕 증대 여부에 대한 응답에 차이가 있는 것으로 나타났다. 이 연구는 대학교육에서 팀 학습 활동을 성공적으로 수행하기 위한 방향을 제시하였다는 점에서 의의가 있다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 민혜리, "학생들이 생각하는 좋은 강의에 대한 연구" 3 : 11-14, 2004

2 Michaelssen, L. K., "팀 기반 학습" 학지사 2009

3 이동원, "집단경쟁과 집단무경쟁 협동학습이 학업성취와 학습동기에 미치는 영향" 계명대학교 1992

4 이영민, "웹 기반 팀 학습환경에서 사회적 친밀감과 학습자의 참여도 및 과제수행 간 상관분석" 한국정보교육학회 10 (10): 307-314, 2006

5 Dyer, W. G., "세계 초일류 조직을 위한 팀 빌딩" 삼성북스 2005

6 최윤미, "대학에서의 ‘좋은 팀웍’의 특성 및 유형에 대한 대학원생의 인식 연구" 교육연구소 10 (10): 257-283, 2009

7 Bligh, D. A., "What's the use of lectures. Harmondsworth" Penguin 1972

8 Lancaster, K., "Using the team-learning model in a managerial accounting class:An experiment in cooperative learning" 16 (16): 549-567, 2001

9 Miglietti, C., "Using cooperative small groups in introductory accounting classes:A practical approach" 78 (78): 111-115, 2002

10 Kogut, L., "Using collaborative learning to enhance performance in general chemistry" 74 (74): 720-722, 1997

11 Salas, E., "Toward an understanding of team performance and training, in Teams" Ablex 1992

12 Shevlin, M., "The validity of student evaluations of teaching in higher education:love me,love my lectures?" 25 (25): 397-405, 2000

13 Miller, D. L., "The stages of group development:A retrospective study of dynamic team processes" 20 (20): 121-134, 2003

14 Bolton, M. K., "The role of coaching in student teams: A “Just-in-Time” approach to learning" 23 (23): 233-250, 1999

15 Chambers, B., "The relationship between student team learning outcomes and achievement,causal attributions,and affect" 83 (83): 140-146, 1991

16 Topping, K., "The peer tutoring handbook:Promoting cooperative learning" Croom Helm 1998

17 Mathieu, J. E., "The influence of shared mental models on team process and performance" 85 (85): 273-283, 2000

18 Prater, E., "The impact of coordination methods on the enhancement of business writing" 1 (1): 57-71, 2003

19 Wales, C. E., "The guided design approach" Educational Technology Publications 1978

20 Hooper, S., "The effects of group composition on achievement,interaction,and learning efficiency during computer-based cooperative instruction" 39 (39): 27-40, 1991

21 Jehn, K. A., "The dynamic nature of conflict:A longitudinal study of intergroup conflict and group performance" 44 (44): 238-251, 2001

22 Neer, M. R., "The development of an instrument to measure classroom comprehension" 36 : 154-166, 1987

23 Clark, M. C., "Team-based learning in an undergraduate nursing course" 47 (47): 111-117, 2008

24 McInerney, M. J., "Team-based learning enhances long-term retention and critical thinking in an undergraduate microbial physiology course" 4 (4): 3-12, 2003

25 Searle, N. S., "Team learning in medical education:Initial experiences at ten institutions" 78 (78): 55-58, 2003

26 Hernandez, S. A., "Team learning in a marketing principles course: Cooperative structures that facilitate active learning and higher level thinking" 24 (24): 73-85, 2002

27 Maier, M., "Teaching tools: Cooperative learning in economics" 32 (32): 358-361, 1994

28 McKeachie, W. J., "Teaching thinking. NCRIPTAL Update, 1"

29 Treisman, P. U., "Study of the mathematics performance of Black students at the University of California, Berkeley" 47 : 1641-, 1985

30 Deeter-Schmeltz, D., "Student team performance:A method for classroom assessment" 20 (20): 85-93, 1998

31 Feingold, C. E., "Student perceptions of team learning in nursing education" 47 (47): 214-222, 2008

32 Koppenhaver, G. D., "Structuring the classroom for performance:Cooperative learning with instructor-assigned teams" 1 (1): 1-21, 2003

33 Janz, B. D., "Self-directed team in IS:Correlations for improved systems development work outcomes" 35 (35): 171-192, 1999

34 Slavin, R. E., "Research in cooperative learning:Consensus and controversy" 47 (47): 52-55, 1990

35 Stout, R. J., "Planning, shared mental models, and coordinated performance: An empirical link is established" 41 (41): 61-71, 1999

36 Langan-Fox, J., "Mental model,team mental model,and performance:Process,development,and future directions" 14 (14): 331-352, 2004

37 Parmelee, D. X., "Medical students' attitudes about team-based learning in a pre-clinical curriculum" 14 (14): 1-6, 2009

38 Mikkelsen, A., "Measuring organizational learning climate:A cross-national replication and instrument validation study among public sector employees" 19 (19): 121-134, 2000

39 Robbins, T. L., "Meaningfulness and community in the classroom:The role of teamwork in business education" 69 (69): 312-316, 1994

40 Jaques, D., "Learning in groups" Kogan Page Publishing 2000

41 Johnson, D. W., "Joining together:Group theory and group skills" Prentice-Hall 1991

42 Astin, A. W., "Involvement: The cornerstone of excellence" 17 : 35-39, 1985

43 Johnson, D. W., "Interdependence and interpersonal attraction among heterogeneous and homogeneous individuals:A theoretical formulation and a meta-analysis of research" 53 (53): 5-54, 1983

44 Smith, D. G., "Instruction and outcomes in an undergraduate setting" 1980

45 Johnson, D. W., "Implementing cooperative learning" 63 (63): 173-180, 1992

46 Siciliano, J., "How to incorporate cooperative learning principles in the classroom: It's more than putting students in teams" 25 (25): 8-20, 2001

47 Levi, D., "Group dynamics for teams" Sage Publications 2007

48 Brooks, C. M., "Free riding in group projects and the effects of timing, frequency, and specificity of criteria in peer assessments" 77 (77): 268-272, 2003

49 Espinosa, J. A., "Explicit versus implicit coordination mechanism and task dependencies: One size does not fit all, in Team cognition" APA 2004

50 Kunkel, J. G., "Effects of student team learning in undergraduate auditing courses" 72 (72): 197-200, 1997

51 Johnson, D. W., "Effects of cooperative,competitive,and individualistic goal structures on achievement:A meta-analysis" 89 (89): 47-62, 1981

52 Cavalier, J .C., "Effects of cooperative learning on performance, attitude, and group behaviors in a technical team environment" 43 (43): 61-71, 1995

53 Tinto, V., "Dropout from higher education:A theoretical synthesis of recent research" 45 : 89-125, 1975

54 Alge, B. J., "Does the medium matter? Knowledge building experiences and opportunities in decision-making teams" 91 (91): 26-37, 2003

55 Hampton, D., "Does cooperative learning mean equal learning?" 72 (72): 5-7, 1996

56 Slavin, R. E., "Cooperative learning:Student teams(2nd ed.)" National Education Association 1987

57 Slavin, R. E., "Cooperative learning: Theory, research and practice" Prentice-Hall 1995

58 Dansereau, D. F., "Cooperative learning: Impact on acquisition of knowledge and skills" 1983

59 Johnson, D. W., "Cooperative learning returns to college:What evidence is there that is works?" 30 (30): 26-35, 1998

60 Millis, B. J., "Cooperative learning or higher education faculty" Phoenix, AX: Oryx. 1998

61 Cooper, J., "Cooperative learning and college teaching:Tips from the trenches" 4 (4): 1-2, 1990

62 Cooper J. S., "Cooperative learning and college instruction: Effective use of student learning teams" California State University Foundation 1990

63 Slavin, R. E., "Cooperative learning" 50 (50): 315-342, 1980

64 Kulik, J. A., "College teaching, in Research on teaching: Concepts, findings and implications" McCutcheon 1979

65 Smith, D. G., "College classroom interactions and critical thinking" 69 : 180-190, 1977

66 Levesque, L. L., "Cognitive divergence and shared mental models in software development project teams" 22 (22): 135-144, 2001

67 Johnson, D. W., "Circles of learning: Cooperation in the classroom (5th ed.)" Interaction Book Company 2002

68 Fink, L. D., "Beyond small groups: Harnessing the extraordinary power of learning teams, in Team-based learning: A transformative use of small groups" Praeger Press 2002

69 Keeler, C., "An assessment of cooperative learning used for basic computer skills instruction in college classroom" 12 (12): 379-393, 1995

70 Kelly, P. A., "A comparison of in-class learner engagement across,problem-based learning,and team learning using the STROBE classroom observation tool" 17 (17): 112-118, 2005