Evaluating a shared decision-making intervention regarding dialysis modality: development and validation of self-assessment items for patients with chronic kidney disease

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Background: Shared decision-making is a two-way symmetrical communication process in which clinicians and patients work together to achieve the best outcome. This study aimed to develop self-assessment items as a decision aid for choosing a dialysis modality in patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD) and to assess the construct validity of the newly developed items. Methods: Five focus group interviews were performed to extract specific self-assessment items regarding patient values in choosing a dialysis modality. After survey items were refined, a survey of 330 patients, consisting of 152 hemodialysis (HD) and 178 peritoneal dialysis (PD) patients, was performed to validate the self-assessment items.Results: The self-assessment for the decision aid was refined to 35 items. The structure of the final items appeared to have three dimensions of factors; health, lifestyle, and dialysis environment. The health factor consisted of 12 subscales (α = 0.724), the lifestyle factor contained 11 subscales (α = 0.624), and the dialysis environment factor was represented by 12 subscales (α = 0.694). A structural equation model analysis showed that the relationship between the decision aid factors (health, lifestyle, and dialysis environment), patients’ CKD perception, and cognition of shared decision-making differed between HD patients and PD patients.Conclusion: We developed and validated self-assessment items as part of a decision aid to help patients with CKD. This attempt may assist CKD patients in making informed and shared decisions closely aligned with their values when considering dialysis modality.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Shay LA, "Where is the evidence? : a systematic review of shared decision making and patient outcomes" 35 : 114-131, 2015

2 Cole DA, "Utility of confirmatory factor analysis in test validation research" 55 : 584-594, 1987

3 Harwood L, "Understanding pre-dialysis modality decision-making : a meta-synthesis of qualitative studies" 50 : 109-120, 2013

4 홍유아 ; 반태현 ; 강채영 ; Hwang Sun Deuk ; 최선령 ; 이하정 ; Jung Hee-Yeon ; 김경민 ; 권영은 ; 김수현 ; Kim Tae Hee ; Koo Ho-Seok ; Yoon Chang-Yun ; Kim Kiwon ; Park Jongha ; Kim Yong Kyun, "Trends in epidemiologic characteristics of end-stage renal disease from 2019 Korean Renal Data System (KORDS)" 대한신장학회 40 (40): 52-61, 2021

5 Morton RL, "The views of patients and carers in treatment decision making for chronic kidney disease : systematic review and thematic synthesis of qualitative studies" 340 : c112-, 2010

6 Polit DF, "The content validity index : are you sure you know what’s being reported? : critique and recommendations" 29 : 489-497, 2006

7 Cuttance P, "Structural modeling by example: applications in educational, sociological, and behavioral research" Cambridge University Press 1987

8 Fornell C, "Structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement error : algebra and statistics" 18 : 382-388, 1981

9 Anderson JC, "Structural equation modeling in practice : a review and recommended two-step approach" 103 : 411-, 1988

10 Dowdy S, "Statistics for research" John Wiley & Sons 2011

11 Kline RB, "Software review : software programs for structural equation modeling : Amos, EQS, and LISREL" 16 : 343-364, 1998

12 Porter AC, "Predictors and outcomes of health-related quality of life in adults with CKD" 11 : 1154-1162, 2016

13 Lee A, "Patients’ views regarding choice of dialysis modality" 23 : 3953-3959, 2008

14 오국환, "Patient education and care for end-stage kidney disease: one size never fits all" 대한신장학회 39 (39): 384-386, 2020

15 Park JI, "Not early referral but planned dialysis improves quality of life and depression in newly diagnosed end stage renal disease patients : a prospective cohort study in Korea" 10 : e0117582-, 2015

16 Australian Commission on Safety and Quality in Healthcare (ACSQHC), "National safety and quality health service standards" ACSQHC

17 Hair JF, "Multivariate data analysis: global edition" Pearson Education 2010

18 Thomas B, "Maintenance dialysis throughout the world in years 1990 and 2010" 26 : 2621-2633, 2015

19 Polit DF, "Is the CVI an acceptable indicator of content validity? : appraisal and recommendations" 30 : 459-467, 2007

20 Coronado-Vázquez V, "Interventions to facilitate shared decision-making using decision aids with patients in primary health care : a systematic review" 99 : e21389-, 2020

21 Lee Jeonghwan ; Kim Yong Chul ; Kwon Soie ; 리려림 ; Oh Sohee ; Kim Do Hyoung ; An Jung Nam ; Cho Jang-Hee ; 김동기 ; Kim Yong-Lim ; 오윤규 ; Lim Chun Soo ; 김연수 ; 이정표, "Impact of health-related quality of life on survival after dialysis initiation: a prospective cohort study in Korea" 대한신장학회 39 (39): 426-440, 2020

22 Roggeri A, "Healthcare costs of the progression of chronic kidney disease and different dialysis techniques estimated through administrative database analysis" 30 : 263-269, 2017

23 Marsh HW, "Goodness of fit in confirmatory factor analysis : the effects of sample size and model parsimony" 28 : 185-217, 1994

24 GBD Chronic Kidney Disease Collaboration, "Global, regional, and national burden of chronic kidney disease, 1990-2017 : a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2017" 395 : 709-733, 2020

25 Rees J, "Exploring the nature of illness perceptions in people with end-stage kidney disease" 44 : 19-29, 2018

26 Cassidy BP, "Educational support around dialysis modality decision making in patients with chronic kidney disease : qualitative study" 5 : 2054358118803323-, 2018

27 Kim SH, "Economic burden of chronic kidney disease in Korea using national sample cohort" 30 : 787-793, 2017

28 Schilling LS, "Determining content validity of a self-report instrument for adolescents using a heterogeneous expert panel" 56 : 361-366, 2007

29 Stacey D, "Decision aids for people facing health treatment or screening decisions" (10) : CD001431-, 2011

30 Hu LT, "Cutoffcriteria for fit indexes in covariance structure analysis : conventional criteria versus new alternatives" 6 : 1-55, 1999

31 Campbell DT, "Convergent and discriminant validation by the multitrait-multimethod matrix" 56 : 81-105, 1959

32 Galla JH, "Clinical practice guideline on shared decision-making in the appropriate initiation of and withdrawal from dialysis. The Renal Physicians Association and the American Society of Nephrology" 11 : 1340-1342, 2000

33 Wheaton B, "Assessing reliability and stability in panel models" 8 : 84-136, 1977

34 Kaiser HF, "An index of factorial simplicity" 39 : 31-36, 1974

35 Visser A, "Accepting or declining dialysis : considerations taken into account by elderly patients with end-stage renal disease" 22 : 794-799, 2009

36 Murray MA, "A systematic review of factors influencing decision-making in adults living with chronic kidney disease" 76 : 149-158, 2009