여러 가지 기기에서의 각막곡률 비교 = Comparison of Corneal Curvatures Obtained with Different Devices

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose: To evaluate device efficacy using the corneal curvature value. Methods: Prospectively, 35 patients (70 eyes) were enrolled in the present study. Three sets of corneal curvature values were obtained using the autorefractor (RK-F1Ⓡ), manual keratometer (OM-2Ⓡ), partial coherence interferometry keratometer (IOL MasterⓇ), wavefront analyzer (KR-1WⓇ), and videokeratography (Orbscan IIⓇ). Repeatability of each device was evaluated by coefficient of variation, standard deviation, and intraclass correlation coefficient. RM-ANOVA on ranks was used to compare the differences in corneal curvatures among the devices. The Bland-Altman plot was performed to assess measurement agreement among the devices. Results: The coefficient of variation values from each device ranged from 2.92% (IOL masterⓇ) to 3.06% (Orbscan IIⓇ), and the values of intraclass correlation coefficient ranged from 0.965 (KR-1WⓇ) to 0.997 (IOL masterⓇ). Compared with the manual keratometer, there was a maximum corneal curvature difference of 1.23 D in KR-1WⓇ, while the other devices had differences less than 0.82 D. Conclusions: When assessing corneal curvature, the repeatability values were similar among the 5 devices, although a difference greater than 1 D was observed when comparing the KR-1WⓇ to the manual keratometer. J Korean Ophthalmol Soc 2012;53(5):618-625

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김찬수, "정시안에서 연령에 따른 안수치들의 변화" 대한안과학회 49 (49): 425-432, 2008

2 맹효성, "전방깊이와 안축장에 따른 인공수정체 삽입 후 굴절 오차의 경향" 대한안과학회 51 (51): 195-202, 2010

3 신영주, "두 가지 각막지형도 검사에서의 각막 측정값 비교" 대한안과학회 48 (48): 637-641, 2007

4 조동현, "각막굴절교정수술 후 인공수정체 도수 결정시 Orbscan II 비디오각막경의 유용성" 대한안과학회 50 (50): 1730-1734, 2009

5 박상준, "WaveScan 수차계의 굴절량과 현성굴절검사 및 자동굴절검사의 굴절량의 비교분석" 대한안과학회 50 (50): 684-690, 2009

6 Hayashi K, "Topographic analysis of the changes in corneal shape due to aging" 14 : 527-532, 1995

7 Olsen T., "Sources of error in intraocular lens power calculation" 18 : 125-129, 1992

8 Norrby S, "Sources of error in intraocular lens power calculation" 34 : 368-376, 2008

9 Kawamorita T, "Repeatability, reproducibility, and agreement characteristics of rotating Scheimpflug photography and scanning-slit corneal topography for corneal power measurement" 35 : 127-133, 2009

10 Elliott M, "Repeatability and accuracy of automated refraction: a comparison of the Nikon NRK-8000, the Nidek AR-1000, and subjective refraction" 74 : 434-438, 1997

11 Hosny M, "Relationship between anterior chamber depth, refractive state, corneal diameter, and axial length" 16 : 336-340, 2000

12 Olsen T., "Prediction of the effective postoperative (intraocular lens) anterior chamber depth" 32 : 419-424, 2006

13 Cairns G, "Orbscan computerized topography: attributes, applications, and limitations" 31 : 205-220, 2005

14 Kiely PM, "Meridional variations of corneal shape" 61 : 619-626, 1984

15 Speicher L, "Intra-ocular lens calculation status after corneal refractive surgery" 12 : 17-29, 2001

16 Holladay JT, "Improving the predictability of intraocular lens power calculations" 104 : 539-541, 1986

17 Findl O, "Improved prediction of intraocular lens power using partial coherence interferometry" 27 : 861-867, 2001

18 최재혁, "IOL Master로 측정된 생체 계수의 재현성과 정확성" 대한안과학회 45 (45): 10-10, 2004

19 Findl O, "High precision biometry of pseudophakic eyes using partial coherence interferometry" 24 : 1087-1093, 1998

20 Qazi MA, "Determining corneal power using Orbscan II videokeratography for intraocular lens calculation after excimer laser surgery for myopia" 33 : 21-30, 2007

21 Mamalis N, "Complications of foldable intraocular lenses requiring explanation or secondary intervention--1998 survey" 26 : 766-772, 2000

22 Solomon KD, "Comparison of wavefront sensing devices" 17 : 119-127, 2004

23 Elbaz U, "Comparison of different techniques of anterior chamber depth and keratometric measurements" 143 : 48-53, 2007

24 Shirayama M, "Comparison of corneal power obtained from 4 different devices" 148 : 528-535, 2009

25 Menassa N, "Comparison and reproducibility of corneal thickness and curvature readings obtained by the Galilei and the Orbscan II analysis systems" 34 : 1742-1747, 2008

26 Koranyi G, "Anterior chamber depth measurement: a-scan versus optical methods" 28 : 243-247, 2002

27 Huynh SC, "An evaluation of keratometry in 6-year-old children" 25 : 383-387, 2006

28 Holzer MP, "Accuracy of a new partial coherence interferometry analyser for biometric measurements" 93 : 807-810, 2009