대한척추외과학회에서 구연된 논문에 대한 추적 관찰 = Observational Analysis of Korean Society of Spine Surgery Annual Congress: (2001-05) Free Paper: From Presentation to Publication

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Study Design: A review of all presentations at the Korean Society of Spine Surgery(KSSS) congress from 2001 to 2005.
Objectives: To determine the presentation to publication rate in peer-reviewed journals of abstracts presented at the KSSS congress and evaluate the consistency between the presented abstract and published full-text counterpart.
Summary of Literature Review: The rate of publication for presentation at international meetings has been determined but there has been no study for the KSSS.
Material and Methods: This study reviewed all podium presentations of the past KSSS Spring and Fall meetings from 2001 to 2005. A computer search for each abstract was performed. The final published journal, time to publication and publication rate were evaluated according to subspecialty. The published full-text article was compared with the original abstract and evaluated for consistency with respect to the author, material and method, and result.
Results: A total of 288 free-papers were identified, of which 167 of them were published as full-text articles. The mean time to publication was 12.15 months. The publication rates according to the subspecialty were basic 67%, lumbar 68%, cervical 64%, deformity 50%, trauma 53%, minimal 14% and others 51%, respectively.
Conclusion: The presentation to publication rate of the Korean society of spine surgery podium presentations was lower than other international meetings but the articles showed a high consistency rate.
Key Word: Korean Society of Spine Surgery congress, Presentation, Publication

국문 초록 (Abstract)

연구계획: 2001년부터 2005년까지 대한척추외과학회에서 구연된 논문을 검토하였다.
목적: 대한 척추 외과 학회에서 구연된 논문의 게재 여부 및 그 내용의 변경 정도를 분석하고 외국의 경우와 비교해 보고자 하였다.
선행문헌의 요약: 주요 국제학회의 경우 구연된 논문의 출간 여부에 대한 연구가 있었으나 국내 척추학회에서는 그 시도가 없었다.
대상 및 방법: 2001년 춘계부터 2005년 추계학회까지 총 10번의 연례 학회에서 구연된 288편의 논문을 분석하였다. 출간 여부는 온라인상으로 확인하였으며 최종 게재된 학술지와 출간 소요 기간, 분야 별 게재율을 분석하였고, 게재된 논문에 대하여 학회에서 발표된 초록을 기준으로 게재 논문 상 저자의 변경여부, 대상 및 결론의 변경 여부를 확인하였다.
결과: 총 288편 중 167편(58%)이 게재 확인되었으며 게재까지의 평균 기간은 12.15개월이었다. 각 분야 별로 기초, 요추, 경추, 변형, 외상, 미세 침습,기타의 게재율은 각각 67%, 68%, 64%, 50%, 53%, 14%, 51%이었다. 최종 게재 시 초록의 내용을 일부 변경한 경우는 저자가 35편, 대상이 32편, 결론이 28편이었으며 모두 일치하는 경우는 국내논문 92편, 국외논문 17편이었다.
결론: 대한 척추외과 학회의 구연 논문은 동일 기간의 외국 학회에 비해 최종 게재율은 낮았으나 내용의 일치율은 높았다.
색인 단어: 대한척추외과학회, 구연, 게재약칭 제목: 대한척추외과학회 구연 논문

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Nguyen V, "Tornetta P 3rd, Bkaric M. Publication rates for the scientific sessions of the OTA. Orthopaedic Trauma Association" 12 : 457-459, 1998

2 Wang JC, "The publication rates of presentations at major Spine Specialty Society meetings (NASS, SRS, ISSLS)" 24 : 425-427, 1999

3 "The natural history and fate of SRS presentations (2000-04) -Accepted for presentation at 44th annual meeting of Scoliosis research society"

4 Schein M, "Redundant surgical publications: tip of the iceberg" 129 : 655-661, 2001

5 Mojon-Azzi SM, "Redundant pulications in scientific ophthalmologic journals. The tip of the iceberg" 111 : 863-866, 2004

6 Lloyd EW, "Publication rates of scientific presentations at the American Association of Hip and Knee Surgeons annual meetings from 1996 to 2001" 21 : 2-5, 2006

7 Yoo S, "Publication rates of presentations made at annual meetings of the American Orthopaedic Society for Sports Medicine and the Arthroscopy Association of North America" 31 : 367-369, 2002

8 Byerly WG, "Publication rates of abstracts from two pharmacy meetings" 34 : 1123-1127, 2000

9 Daluiski A, "Publication rate of abstracts presented at the annual meeting of the Orthopaedic Research Society" 16 : 645-649, 1998

10 Hamlet WP, "Publication patterns of papers presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons" 79 : 1138-1143, 1997

11 Gorman RL, "Publication of presented abstracts at annual scientific meetings: a measure of quality" 32 : 470-472, 1990

12 Jackson KR, "Publication of abstracts submitted to the annual meeting of the Pediatric Orthopaedic Society of North America" 20 : 2-6, 2000

13 Kim YJ, "Publication Patterns of Paper Presented at the Annual Fall Congress of the Korean Orthopaedic Association" 33 : 472-476, 1998

14 "Observational analysis of CSRS annual meeting:(2000-04) Fre-papers: From presentation to publication"

15 Scherer R, "Full publication of results initially published in abstracts" JAMA. 272 : 159-162, 1994

16 Hahm CK, "Ethical issues of multiple publication" 50 : 375-381, 2007

17 Rosenthal EL, "Dupilcate publications in the otolaryngology literature" 113 : 772-774, 2003

18 Riordan FA, "Do presenters to paediatric meetings get their work published" 93 : 524-526, 2000

19 Von Elm E, "Different patterns of duplicate publication: an analysis of articles used in systematic reviews" 291 : 974-980, 2004

20 Cho BK, "Bodnar E, Waldhausen Ja. Joint statement on redundant (duplicate) publication" 13 : 417-, 1998

21 Sprague S, "Barriers to full-text publication following presentation of abstracts at annual orthopaedic meetings" 85 : 158-63, 2003